Cost Comparison: Fiberglass insert vs. replace 5' dia x 10' deep concrete manhole
|
Fiberglass insert acid resistant to 98%
- Block lane
- Hydroblast manhole wall
- Rehabilitate bench
- Cut street 8' x 8'
- Remove old cone
- Drop in inserts sections
- Grout annular space
- Place Composite cone
- Backfill around cone
- Coat bench
- Set adjustment rings
- Pave street
- Elapsed time – 6-8 hours
- Cost – $12,500
- Warranty – 25 plus years
|
Replace deteriorated concrete manhole zero acid resistant
- Divert traffic
- Cut street 15' x 15'
- Excavate 15' x 15' hole
- Bypass any phone, gas, water and electric lines
- Remove old manhole
- Rehabilitate bench
- Set new manhole
- Reconnect phone, gas, water and electric lines
- Backfill hole and area around cone
- Set adjustment rings
- Pave street
- Elapsed time – 5-10 days + weather allowance
- Cost – $30,000 to $40,000 depending on utilities
- Warranty – 1 year
|
Cost Comparison: New 5' dia. x 10' deep fiberglass manhole vs. a new lined concrete
manhole over 28 years
| |
Fiberglass Manhole |
Lined Concrete Manhole |
Difference |
| Manhole with cone |
$6,766 |
$3,500 (2005) |
|
| Interior liner |
$0 |
$2,850 |
|
| Initial outlay (not including installation) |
$6,766 |
$6,350 |
$635 per v.f. |
| |
| Rehabilitation (every 7 years w/3% inflation) |
$0 |
$4,670 (2012) |
($1,102) per v.f. |
| |
$0 |
$5,743 (2019) |
($1,676.30) per v.f. |
| |
$0 |
$7,064 (2026) |
($2,382.70) per v.f. |
| |
$0 |
$7,950 (2033) |
($3,177.70) per v.f. |
| Total: |
$6,766 |
$31,777 (4x) |
|
| After 28 years the final breakdown of costs are: |
| 157 sq.ft. = |
$43.09 per sq.ft.
or
$676.91 per v.f.
|
$202.40 per sq.ft.
or
$3,177.70 per v.f.
|
|